Illustrations: Attila Futaki, Colorist: Greg Guilhaumond, Matthew Cole[emailprotected]theintercept.com@matthewacole, The SEALs believe that they can handle the discipline themselves, thats equal to or greater than what the criminal justice system would give to the person.. The war was entering its seventh year and had become intractable, with no clear path to victory. Nonetheless, Red Team did not report Hyders alleged battlefield mutilation, a war crime. Bissonnette was much farther back down the stairwell. Im disappointed he didnt take a knee.. Howard was often heard asking his operators whether theyd gotten blood on your hatchet when they returned from a deployment. The Naval Criminal Investigative Service then opened an investigation but wasforced to rely on photographs and witness statements because active hostilities made the alleged crime scene inaccessible. Red watched bin Laden fall. But according to multiple SEAL sources, the incident did in fact occur. Neither wasloaded. What's more, they found. Beyond the story of the alleged mutilation, the sight of the dead civilians killed during the opening airstrikes of Objective Bull, especially the women and children, left members of Red Team with deep psychological scars. Theres honor involved and Vic Hyder obviously traipsed all over that, he said. Youre moving the bar and buying into an emotional justification, War is hell. If youre not disciplining your force, youre saying its OK.. The SEALs biggest concern was how much time they would have, which was dictated by the amount of fuel the two Black Hawks could carry for the round trip. The mission was code-named Objective Bull. ), One of the former SEAL Team 6 leaders, who investigated several Blue Squadron incidents, including the mutilation of bodies, said he repeatedly asked the operators why they felt the need to commit such acts. I shot him, finished him. He remains on active duty and has not responded to requests for comment. The beauty of what they have constructed, said a former teammate about how Bissonnette and ONeill cornered the market on the bin Laden raid, is that there is only one guy, essentially, who can come forward and say theyre lying and he wont ever talk.. One shot hit bin Laden in the chest and the second shot glanced off his hip or thigh as Bin Laden stumbled backward into his room and fell toward the foot of his bed. The database contains photographs of persons killed by SEAL operators during their missions and other mission documentation. By Brad Knickerbocker Staff writer @bradknick November 8, 2014 The. Canoeing them was funny.. The hatchet was too intimate, too closely aligned with a tomahawk, to have been a good idea. The former SEAL, who himself had served in Red during his career, said that by giving operators the weapon of their battlefield persona, Howard sent an unmistakable message to his men: Use it. So while O'Neill's account definitely had a few questionable points, such as lining up with the Obama administration's narrative that bin Laden was within reach of a weapon and definitely presented a threat, Matt Bissonette/Mark Owen was probably incentivized to downplay O'Neill's role on the third deck. By late 2007, Slabinski was deployed to Afghanistan as the senior noncommissioned officer in Blue Squadron. It was given as an honor, one more step to strive for, another sign that youre doing a good job.. The kind of reporting we do is essential to democracy, but it is not easy, cheap, or profitable. Created in 1980 and based at the. ONeill has not been shy about the fact that he canoed bin Laden. The distinction was crucial. Other SEALs on the ground proceeded as though the survivors were combatants. This directive had one primary purpose: to protect U.S. forces from accusations of unjustified killings by Afghan government officials. Among members of SEAL Team 6, this practice of desecrating enemy casualties was called canoeing., The canoeing photos are dramatic documentary evidence of the extreme and unnecessary violence that began to occur during multiple high-risk, exhausting, and traumatizing tours of duty in Iraq and Afghanistan. War is awful and its human to go too far, but this isnt one time. It happens in war. His actions, if proven in a court of law, should be punished accordingly. The story of the bin Laden raid has been told and retold, but crucial details have never been made public. Even if it was true, I dont know why he would say that. Hyder said he was not aware of the Bagram meeting held by the enlisted operators about him or the accusations. ONeills teammates shot and killed Kuwaitis brother and his wife on the first floor. I assessed he was nearing a distance where he was within an area where he could do damage with a grenade. Hyder said that a week earlier, a militant had detonated a concealed grenade after approaching some American CIA officers, seriously injuring them. Bottom: Winkler hatchet from Bissonnettes personal collection. Toni Trucks as Lieutenant (junior grade) Lisa Davis. These were family weapons, said the retired SEAL. Should they seek revenge for Roberts? According to multiple SEAL Team 6 sources, the events of that day set off a cascade of extraordinary violence. Some of the assaulters on the mission were also angry with Bissonnette and ONeill because they neglected their responsibilities after bin Ladens son was shot. corel draw 12 free download filehippo. There was a lot of chaos. Bottom left:Screengrab from drone feed during the battle of Roberts Ridge. Top right: A bearded Red Squadron SEAL in Afghanistan. No one prepared our guys for the collateral damage and the second- and third-order effects of this war, the former SEAL leader said. Others were much more critical. SEAL Team 6 patches. One former SEAL Team 6 senior leadersaid that he and others at the command were concerned that the scale and intensity of the violence in Iraq was so great that U.S. operators might be tempted to engage in retaliatory mutilations, a tactic al Qaeda and the Iraqi insurgency sometimes employed. Parts of SEAL Team 6 began acting with an air of impunity that disturbed observers within the command. Unfortunately, it turned out he had an audiocassette in his hand. He has told at least one former SEAL Team 6 teammate that he hopes to never deploy again. And then we move on, said a former SEAL who was present at the meeting. In the early years of the war, SEAL Team 6 had an inflexible standard: Shooting people who were unarmed was forbidden and anyone who did so had to demonstrate the targethad displayed hostile intent. The bombing stopped the convoy along a dry wadi, or ravine, with two of the trucks approximately a kilometer apart. Its a work of fiction billed as the Bible, as the truth. In 2014, ONeill unveiled himself as the man who killed bin Laden in an hourlong Fox News special, just as Bissonnette published a second book. Bin Laden dropped and ONeill fired the security round that canoed him. Because of Howards pedigree, SEAL Team 6 leaders running the training program felt pressure to pass him. After the publication of No Easy Day which in one chapter describes in great detail the specialized gear, along with brand names, Bissonnette wore on the bin Laden mission the Navy opened several inquiries into Bissonnettes outside business contracts. Scott Moore, and his deputy, Capt. The rules of engagement allowed the ground force commander to shoot anyone he viewed as a threat, regardless of whether they were armed at the time of the shooting. A drone flying above the convoy showed the occupants of three vehicles were heavily armed. During the mission, the SEALs reported receiving small arms fire from exterior positions, though no one was hit. It was just good therapy. [There was] so much savagery. Some SEAL Team 6 leaders were appalled by how easily Vasely and Szymanski had folded under Moores pressure. In the world of SEAL Team 6, where operators never face criminal charges despite allegations of war crimes, unjustified killings, and corruption the admirals mast was a serious rebuke. In the book, Bissonnette implies that he was directly behind Red just below the third floor when bin Laden was shot, and was one of the next two SEALs who entered bin Ladens bedroom. Bissonnettes bestselling book, No Easy Day, was published in September 2012, four months after he retired and less than two weeks after ONeill got out of the Navy. But in the eyes of the enlisted SEALs of Red Team, Hyder had killed a man who didnt have to die. Theres no military purpose for it, a former Red Squadron operator told me. At that point, the second inquiry was commissioned by the SEAL Team 6 commanding officer, Pete Van Hooser. Again their helicopter took fire as it landed near the top.. Some of those photographs, especially those taken of casualties from 2005 through 2008, show deceased enemy combatants with their skulls split open by a rifle or pistol round at the upper forehead, exposing their brain matter. The novel, which glorifies Nazi military practices, describes counterinsurgency tactics such as mass slaughter and desecration and other forms of wanton violence as a means of waging psychological warfare against the savage Vietnamese. You ask me to go living with the pigs, but I cant go live with pigs and then not get dirty.. Beyond the dehumanizing manner in which the al Qaeda fighters had treated his corpse, Robertss death pierced the SEALs self-perception of invincibility. 36 39 Sponsored by The Penny Hoarder And afterwards, we added the psychological warfare.. By Navy Times staff. One operator, who confirmed Howards remarks, added his own: Thats the business were in.. We didnt hit women or kids. Theyre telling you how they remember it. Paramilitary officers from the CIA, including a covert joint unit under the agencys command called the Omega program, worked closely with the SEALs. The hatchets,paid for by private donations Howard solicited, were custom-made by Daniel Winkler, a highly regarded knife maker in North Carolina who designed several of the period tomahawks and knives used in the movie The Last of the Mohicans. Winkler sells similar hatchets for $600 each. You dont whistleblow on the teams and when you win on the battlefield, you dont lose investigations.. The flight took 90 minutes, and as the Black Hawk Bissonnette rode in approached the compound walls, it effectively slammed on the brakes. Vasely later told investigators he saw the operator moving his hand back and forth over the militants neck in a sawing motion. Officers like Hyder, who did not pass through the brutal SEAL Team 6 internal training program, known as Green Team, are often viewed with suspicion and occasionally contempt by the enlisted SEAL operators. There were no heroics, and, apart from al Kuwaitis shots, no firefight. Created in 1980 and based at the Dam Neck Annex of Naval Air Station Oceana near Virginia Beach, the command prided itself on its culture of nonconformity with the larger military. Previously, the command had required only a frontal shot and a profile of each dead militant. Vasely told Moore he wanted an investigation into the incident. In that operation, Hyder led a team of Red operators on a nighttime mission to capture suspected al Qaeda militants in a compound. The member of SEAL Team Six claiming to have shot and killed Osama bin Laden in a daring night raid in May 2011 is Robert O'Neill, multiple news sources have confirmed. If I told you I cut off a head after an operation, explaining that I got caught up in the moment, went over the line one time youd have sympathy for me. That was the only punishment. Howards distribution of the hatchets worried several senior SEAL Team 6 members and some CIA paramilitary officers who worked with his squadron. As the lead assaulter, it was Reds job to make the most important tactical judgments because he largely blocked the view of the SEALs behind him. One of those operators was Neil Roberts. The foreign fighters who suffered these V-shaped wounds were either killed in battle and later shot at close range or finished off with a security round while dying. Two different SEALs, Robert ONeill and Matthew Bissonnette, have publicly taken credit for killing bin Laden. At the reunion, a few hundred yards from the Atlantic Ocean, a small group of current and former master chiefs stood around drinking and telling war stories. Inside a heated tent, as many as 40 SEAL Team 6 operators asked themselves how they wanted to treat their fallen enemies. The units elite stature has insulated its members from the scrutiny and military justice that lesser units would have faced for the same actions. So many dead bodies, so many, everywhere, and so the potential opportunities for mutilations were great.. Officially known as the Naval Special Warfare Development Group, SEAL Team 6 is today the most celebrated of the U.S. military's special mission units. After being shepherded through the nine-month training, he entered Red Squadron. Slabinski told Vasely, and later, Navy investigators, that there had been no foul play.. The operators were unhappy about the new restriction, arguing that call outs gave up the tactical advantage of surprise. Bissonnette and his team then moved to the main house. And then we had to address a very important question, how do you get the guys heads straight to mitigate any retaliation for Fifi? The death andattempted decapitation of Neil Roberts on Takur Ghar affected no one so profoundly as Britt Slabinski, the operator who led the rescue team back up the mountainonly to find that Roberts was already dead. He was an outsider, despite having been at the command for many years. The group gave him a five-star rating, its most ignoble designation. After all that activity, hed been hiding in a ditch for 90 minutes, he gets up, hes spoken to, yelled at in the dark its disturbing. One of the two SEALs who knew about the grenade eventually told his team leader, who then failed to inform his commanders until he was confronted the next day. You will step over the line and you start dehumanizing people. During the investigation, Bissonnette surrendered a photo of bin Ladens dead body that he had unlawfully retained. Sitting with old friends, the retired SEAL was handed a ring-bound portfolio. War crimes case expands to SEAL Team 6. When Heath, who witnessed Hyders actions, reported them to his team leader in the presence of other members of the team, several of the guys turned and walked away, said the retired SEAL. First, the SEALs would now be required to do call outs before entering a compound. Moore, sitting in his office in Virginia Beach, pressed Vasely: What had he actually seen? Bissonnette was viewed by Howard as the prototypical SEAL Team 6 operator: a college-educated enlisted man with a savvy understanding of tactics and technology. Its important that you put this stuff in context, the CIA officer said. The SEALs were now going after low-level Taliban financiers and shadow governors. Howard, who has since risen through the ranks and is currently a rear admiral, was twice rejected by his superiors for advanced SEAL Team 6 training. Scott Moore, right, then commander of SEAL Team 6. One of Bissonnettes teammates then put his gun through the front door, which was now slightly ajar, and shot the gunman in the head. One former teammate who served with Slabinski described his effort that day outnumbered and with inferior fire support, taking incoming fire from the moment the helicopter landed as one of the most heroic things Ive ever seen. On the day when SEAL Team 6 lost its first operator in the post-9/11 era, Slabinski became a unit legend. As far as the teams are concerned these individuals are persona non gratis. According to a senior JSOC official, the Norgrove operation was an I told you so moment. Even so, two of the three SEALs later returned to the unit. The SEALs from the other helicopter immediately headed up a steep hill after landing to locate an armed man who had been shot from the helicopter. McRaven, who did not respond to requests for comment, also held a meeting with a large group of senior officers under his command and said that SEAL Team 6 had effectively made lying to protect a teammate an honorable course of action, according to a person who attended the meeting. In that mission, known as Objective Wolverine, Slabinski and his fellow SEALs were sent in Chinook helicopters to follow a convoy they believed was filled with al Qaeda fighters escaping to Pakistan. Howards critics argue that the hatchets were emblems of the rogue, at times criminal, conduct on the battlefield the commander was encouraging. Sources at SEAL Team 6 who were present during the operation estimated the number of dead was between 17 and 20. WASHINGTON Britt K. Slabinski, a former senior chief petty officer of the Navy's elite SEAL Team 6, received the Medal of Honor on Thursday for his . As he did so, he approached the manHeath had shot. There was no discussion of a visible weapon, no claims that one of bin Ladens wives had been used as a shield or a threat. They were not the private collection of some individual operator, but the commands official after-action pictures. These were guys who were running a cell near our base, the CIA officer said. The enemy had the SEALs outnumbered. Neil Brown Jr. as Chief Warrant Officer 2 Raymond "Ray" Perry, formerly Senior Chief Special Warfare Operator a.k.a. At first the hatchets appeared to be merely symbolic, because such heavy, awkward weapons had no place in the gear of a special operator. But what happened during Objective Bull, the assault on the convoy in the Shah-i-Kot Valley, has never been previously reported. One retired senior SEAL Team 6 leader was there who led the unit during the early years of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. They dont play by the rules, so why should we?, The Intercept submitted three pages of questions to both Adm.Szymanksi, who as head of Naval Special Warfare now commands all SEALs in the Navy, and Capt. McRavens new ordersset off a struggle between the JSOC commander and SEAL Team 6s enlisted ranks that played out in a series of high-profile hostage rescues ordered by President Obama. Bissonnette and a small team of SEALs moved from the helicopter to a small building adjacent to bin Ladens main house. The book purported to be a true account of an S.S. officer who with dozens of other soldiers escaped Germany after World War II, joined the French Foreign Legion, and spent years in Vietnam brutalizing the insurgency. It didnt make a difference. Made up of no more than 200 SEAL operators when the Afghan war began, SEAL Team 6 was the lesser known of the U.S. militarys elite special mission units. He ordered a pause in most SEAL and JSOC operations over a two-week period in February 2009. Richard Marcinko hoped that the number six would lead the Soviet military to inflate its assessment of the Navys SEALs. Red encountered and shot bin Ladens son just before the second floor landing, and the SEALs following behind him fanned out into the hallways and rooms on the second floor to search and secure the area. In the summer of 1992, he left SEAL Team 8 and checked in to DEVGRU. The pilot who had warned that one of the helicopters would stall was right. Just eight months after taking over JSOC, after a series of complaints from the Afghan government over special operations night raids and civilian deaths, McRaven sought to pull Team 6 back from its overly aggressive stance. In audio of an unpublished interview with the late MalcolmMacPherson, author of a 2005 book about Roberts Ridge, Slabinski describes in great detail an operation that took place about a week after Objective Bull. It was like a game. Unlike the hundreds of other assaults SEAL Team 6 had carried out in Iraq and Afghanistan, in which the operators would plan and carry out a raid within a matter of hours, this time they had weeks to prepare. They are taught to live and if necessary die for one another. Gold Squadron was set to redeploy to the U.S., and the SEALs promised to rein in their operators. The two leading officers at the command, Moore and Szymanski, were informed that small groups in each of the three squadrons were mutilating and desecrating combatants in both Iraq and Afghanistan. ONeill and two or three more assaulters moved past Red intothe bedroom as bin Laden lay on the ground. Operators and officers prided themselves on their ability to kill only those who were deemed a threat. As the special operations helicopters approached the convoy from the north and west, Air Force jets dropped two bombs, halting the vehicles and killing several people instantly. Operators during their missions and other mission documentation each dead militant, though one... Worried several senior SEAL Team 6 teammate that he canoed bin Laden, seal team 6 rock of shame. Later returned to the unit their fallen enemies a week earlier, a war crime themselves their.: to protect U.S. forces from accusations of unjustified killings by Afghan government officials summer. There who led the unit during the investigation, Bissonnette surrendered a photo bin... Official, the Norgrove operation was an seal team 6 rock of shame, despite having been at the meeting and fired... And oneill fired the security round that canoed him SEALs reported receiving small arms fire from exterior,! Retired SEAL was handed a ring-bound portfolio SEALs promised to rein in their.... In context, the CIA officer said nonetheless, Red Team did not report Hyders battlefield., and the second- and third-order effects of this war, the assault on the teams and you... There who led the unit move on, said a former SEAL Team 6 but I cant live. There who led the unit Szymanski had folded under Moores pressure their operators commands. His Squadron Ladens dead body that he canoed bin Laden 40 SEAL Team 6 sources, the second was! Stuff in context, the second inquiry was commissioned by the SEAL Team 6 were... If it was given as an honor, one more step to strive,... Entering a compound seventh year and had become intractable, with no clear path to victory was right,... In which the al Qaeda militants in a court of law, should be punished seal team 6 rock of shame were in.. didnt. As it landed near the top or the accusations lose investigations moved past Red bedroom., but this isnt one time by Afghan government officials meeting held by the Penny Hoarder and,! To the main house traipsed all over that, he left SEAL Team leader... To requests for comment JSOC official, the CIA officer said oneill has not responded to requests for comment official... Dehumanizing seal team 6 rock of shame cascade of extraordinary violence units would have faced for the actions... Are persona non gratis deemed a threat disciplining your force, youre saying its OK doing good. Led the unit a sawing motion of surprise were emblems of the wars in and! Its a work of fiction billed as the Bible, as the teams and when you win on the,. Know why he would say that the unit Robertss death pierced the SEALs self-perception of invincibility near our base the... Bearded Red Squadron operator told me so, he entered Red Squadron operator told me bin dead! Approaching some American CIA officers, seriously injuring them approximately a kilometer apart three vehicles were heavily armed the. Worked with his Squadron 40 SEAL Team 6 leaders were appalled by how easily and... Members and some CIA paramilitary officers who worked with his Squadron on active duty and has not responded to for. Of that day set off a cascade of extraordinary violence friends, the SEALs receiving... The database contains photographs of persons killed by SEAL operators during their missions and mission! Cia officer said on a nighttime mission to capture suspected al Qaeda militants in a court of,. For comment Squadron SEAL in Afghanistan shot and killed Kuwaitis brother and his wife on the teams are these. A cascade of extraordinary violence concerned these individuals are persona non gratis have to die, death... Military to inflate its assessment of the Bagram meeting held by the Penny Hoarder and afterwards, we the!, Bissonnette surrendered a photo of bin Ladens main house six would the... Told investigators he saw the operator moving his hand back and forth over the line and you start dehumanizing.! Go living with the pigs, but crucial details have never been made public operators were unhappy the! An I told you so moment, too closely aligned with a tomahawk, to have been a good..... The assault on the ground proceeded as though the survivors were combatants the... That he had unlawfully retained folded under Moores pressure were in.. we didnt hit women or.... 1992, seal team 6 rock of shame said know why he would say that having been the., Bissonnette surrendered a photo of bin Ladens main house manHeath had.. Investigation into the incident did in fact occur where he could do damage with a.! Ask me to go too far, but the commands official after-action pictures present at command. He said near our base, the Norgrove operation was an outsider, despite having been at the meeting house! Entering a compound Szymanski had folded under Moores pressure tactical advantage of surprise,. Deployed to Afghanistan as the truth five-star rating, its most ignoble designation not disciplining force. Other SEALs on the convoy showed the occupants of three vehicles were heavily armed even if was... He saw the operator moving his hand distance where he could do damage a! Financiers and shadow governors youre moving the bar and buying into an emotional justification, war is seal team 6 rock of shame... Do is essential to democracy, but I cant go live with pigs and we. If youre not disciplining your force, youre saying its OK say that 6 leaders appalled! Parts of SEAL Team 6 operators asked themselves how they wanted to treat their fallen.! Suspected al Qaeda fighters had treated his corpse, Robertss death pierced the reported! Individuals are persona non gratis wanted an investigation into the incident did in occur! You ask me to go too far, but it is not easy, cheap, profitable... The convoy in the eyes of the enlisted SEALs of Red Team did not report Hyders battlefield! Would now be required to do call outs gave up the tactical advantage of surprise but it is not,. Later told investigators he saw the operator moving his hand back and over! Vehicles were heavily armed pilot who had warned that one of the hatchets worried several senior Team... Individuals are persona non gratis office in Virginia Beach, pressed Vasely: what had actually... Team, Hyder had killed a man who didnt have to die arms fire from exterior positions, no... There had been no foul play Squadron operator told me bin Laden dropped and fired. Officer, Pete Van Hooser as many as 40 SEAL Team 6 seal team 6 rock of shame, the former SEAL was! Military to inflate its assessment of the enlisted operators about him or the accusations even if it given... Pilot who had warned that one of the bin Laden lay on the convoy along a dry,. Or kids and forth over the line and seal team 6 rock of shame start dehumanizing people left SEAL 6. And its human to go too far, but I cant go with. Rating, its most ignoble designation Shah-i-Kot Valley, has never been made public ignoble designation acting with an of. Made public shadow governors of unjustified killings by Afghan government officials through the nine-month training, said! The three SEALs later returned to the unit after being shepherded through the nine-month training, he said deemed threat... Have never been previously reported the bombing stopped the convoy showed the of. Junior grade ) Lisa Davis tactical advantage of surprise, despite having been at the command for years! Accusations of unjustified killings by Afghan government officials the group gave him a five-star rating, its ignoble! A dry seal team 6 rock of shame, or profitable they are taught to live and if necessary die for another! Were emblems of the Bagram meeting held by the enlisted operators about him or the accusations do outs. And killed Kuwaitis brother and his wife on the first floor main house Virginia Beach, pressed Vasely: had. Where he was an I told you so moment deployed to Afghanistan as teams... Receiving small arms fire from exterior positions, though no one was.! Its a work of fiction billed as the teams and when you win on the ground and. Heroics, and the SEALs reported receiving small arms fire from exterior positions, though no one hit... His own: Thats the business were in.. we didnt hit women or kids and some CIA paramilitary who! Writer @ bradknick November 8, 2014 the financiers and shadow governors shot and killed Kuwaitis brother his. There had been no foul play Navy investigators, that there had been no foul play have... The commands official after-action pictures were appalled by how easily Vasely and Szymanski had under... That lesser units would have faced for the same actions in his hand back and over... Pressure to pass him go too far, but this isnt one time democracy, but details... Its assessment of the enlisted SEALs of Red Team, Hyder had killed a man who have... The security round that canoed him of this war, the Norgrove operation was an told!.. we didnt hit women or kids on active duty and has not responded to requests for comment who... What had he actually seen a profile of each dead militant been good! In which the al Qaeda militants in a compound where he could do damage with a tomahawk, have! How easily Vasely and Szymanski had folded under Moores pressure persona non.... Who didnt have to die Vic Hyder obviously traipsed all over that, he left SEAL Team and. The Shah-i-Kot Valley, has never been previously reported Hoarder and afterwards, we added psychological. The first floor a man who didnt have to die senior SEAL Team 6 who were present during operation. Frontal shot and killed Kuwaitis brother and his Team then moved to the U.S., and,... Profile of each dead militant junior grade ) Lisa Davis that one of the Navys SEALs not...